Options basics

How to Choose a Strike Price for Your Options Trade

In the money or out of the money? A plain-English walk through delta, break-even and cost, using a real NVIDIA trade, with a calculator you can play with.

By Abhi, AD FinanceUpdated 9 min read

Here's something that took me far too long to learn: you can be completely right about where a stock is going and still lose money on the option. Not because you picked the wrong direction, but because you picked the wrong strike.

So let's fix that. I'll use a real example from my video: NVIDIA on March 7, 2025, trading at about $111, with options expiring two weeks later on March 21. We'll compare two calls side by side, a $105 strike and a $120 strike, and by the end you'll know exactly what you give up and what you get with each one.

If words like premium or intrinsic value are still fuzzy, read my options terminology guide first. It'll make this one much easier.

The short answer

The rest of this guide is the why. There are really only three trade-offs to understand.

What a strike price actually is

The strike price is the price at which your option lets you buy or sell the stock. When you buy a call, you get the right, but not the obligation, to buy 100 shares at the strike price any time before expiration. When you buy a put, you get the right to sell 100 shares at the strike.

That's the only difference between the two. A call is a bullish bet, a put is a bearish one. Everything below uses calls to keep things simple, but the same ideas apply to puts, just mirrored.

One more thing worth knowing early: almost nobody actually exercises their options. You buy the contract, and if it goes up in value you sell it back before expiration. The strike still matters a lot though, because it decides how much the contract costs and how it reacts when the stock moves.

In the money vs out of the money

Open any option chain and you'll see a list of strikes, some above the current stock price and some below. Where a strike sits relative to the stock price is what traders call its "moneyness".

CallsPuts
In the money (ITM)Strike below the stock priceStrike above the stock price
At the money (ATM)Strike at or very close to the stock price
Out of the money (OTM)Strike above the stock priceStrike below the stock price

Here's roughly what the NVIDIA call chain looked like that day:

StrikePrice per shareCost of 1 contractDelta
$100$13.40$1,3400.78
$105in the money$9.85$9850.68
$110$6.87$6870.56
NVDA trading at $111
$115$4.51$4510.43
$120out of the money$2.75$2750.31
$125$1.55$1550.20
NVIDIA calls expiring March 21, 2025, with the stock at about $111. Shaded rows are in the money. The $105 and $120 prices are the real quotes from that day. The other rows are modelled from them, so treat them as close, not exact.

Notice the pattern before we even get into it: as you move down the list to higher strikes, the option gets cheaper and the delta gets smaller. That's not a coincidence. It's the whole story.

Trade-off 1: how much the option moves

Delta tells you roughly how much the option's price changes when the stock moves $1. Option prices are quoted per share and one contract covers 100 shares, so a delta of 0.67 means the contract gains about $67 when the stock rises a dollar.

The $105 call had a delta of 0.67. The $120 call had a delta of 0.30. Same stock, same dollar move, very different result:

$105 call · delta 0.67+$67

That's 6.8% of the $985 you paid.

$120 call · delta 0.30+$30

That's 10.9% of the $275 you paid.

What one contract gains if NVIDIA rises $1, using the deltas shown in the broker that day.

In-the-money options track the stock closely. Out-of-the-money options barely notice a small move. But look at that last line under each bar, because there's a twist: as a percentage of what you paid, the cheap option actually gains more. That's the whole appeal of out-of-the-money options. Bigger percentage swings. In both directions, though, and only if the stock really moves.

Two more things about delta that are handy to know. It isn't fixed: as the stock climbs toward and past your strike, delta rises too. And a lot of traders use it as a rough gut check for the odds that the option finishes in the money. A 0.30 delta is roughly a 30% shot. It's not exact, but it's a useful reality check.

Trade-off 2: how far the stock has to go

This is the one most beginners skip, and it's the one that matters most. Your break-even at expiration for a call is simple:

Break-even = strike price + premium you paid

  • $105 call: $105 + $9.85 = $114.85. NVIDIA needs to rise about 3.5% by expiration.
  • $120 call: $120 + $2.75 = $122.75. NVIDIA needs to rise about 10.6% by expiration.
Distance from today's price to each break-even. The longer the bar, the more the stock has to do for you.

NVIDIA is a volatile stock, but a 10.6% gain in two weeks is asking a lot. A 3.5% gain is a normal couple of weeks for it. That's the real meaning of "in-the-money options are less risky": not that you can't lose money, but that the bar for making money is much lower.

Here's the full picture. This chart shows what each contract would be worth on expiration day at every price:

$105 call, paid $985$120 call, paid $275
-$1,000$0+$1,000+$2,000$100$105$110$115$120$125$130$135NVDA price on March 21today $111$114.85$122.75
Profit or loss on one contract held to expiration. Dots mark each break-even. Hover or tap the chart to read exact values.

Look closely at the stretch between $111 and $120. Say NVIDIA has a good run and finishes at $119, up 7%. The $105 call makes $415. The $120 call expires worthless and you lose the full $275. You called the direction right and still lost everything you put in. That's exactly the trap I want you to avoid.

To be fair to the cheap option, it has two things going for it. Its worst case is a much smaller dollar loss ($275 vs $985), and if NVIDIA really rips, say to $135, it returns about 445% on what you paid versus about 205% for the $105 call. Big, fast moves are the only place it wins.

Trade-off 3: what it costs you

The $105 call cost $985 for one contract. The $120 call cost $275. That's $710 more for the in-the-money option, and it's fair to ask what you're getting for it.

The answer is intrinsic value. The $105 call is already $6 in the money, so $600 of the $985 is real value you could capture right now. Only the remaining $385 is "time value", the part that slowly melts away as expiration gets closer. The $120 call has no intrinsic value at all. Every cent of its $275 is time value, so if NVIDIA doesn't get above $120 by March 21, all of it disappears.

$105 call (in the money)$120 call (out of the money)
Cost of 1 contract$985$275
Delta0.670.30
Break-even$114.85 (+3.5%)$122.75 (+10.6%)
If NVDA finishes flat at $111Lose about $385Lose all $275
If NVDA finishes at $119Make $415Lose all $275
If NVDA finishes at $135Make $2,015 (+205%)Make $1,225 (+445%)
Best forA steady move you feel good aboutA big, fast move you can afford to be wrong on

Try it yourself

Reading about this only gets you so far. Drag the strike around and watch what happens to the cost, the delta and the break-even. Then move the second slider to see how each strike would have done at different prices on expiration day.

In the money
$95, deep in the money$130, far out of the money

You pay

$687

$6.87 × 100 shares

Delta

0.56

about +$56 per $1 NVDA rises

Break-even

$116.87

NVDA needs +5.3%

The $110 call would make $113 (+16.4% on what you paid)

Modelled on NVDA at $111 with 14 days to expiration, using volatility fitted to the real quotes from that day. Your broker's numbers will differ a little, and they change every second the market is open.

Pick a strike, then pick where NVIDIA ends up. Everything updates as you drag.

A couple of things to try: set the finish price to $116 and slide the strike from $100 up to $120. Then do the same with the finish price at $130. You'll feel the trade-off much faster than any explanation can give it to you.

So which strike should you pick?

There's no single right strike for everyone, and anybody who tells you otherwise is selling something. But these four questions will get you to a good one almost every time.

1. How big a move do you expect, and how fast?

If you think the stock will drift up a few percent, go in the money or at the money. If you're expecting a big move from a specific catalyst, like earnings, out of the money can make sense. Just be honest with yourself about how often those big moves actually show up on time.

2. How much time do you have?

Short expirations are hardest on out-of-the-money options because time value melts fastest in the last few weeks. If you like OTM strikes, give the trade more time.

3. How much are you willing to lose?

Decide the dollar amount first, then pick the strike. Never buy extra contracts just because they're cheap. Three $275 lottery tickets are still lottery tickets.

4. What does your own history say?

This is the one nobody does. Look back at your last 20 trades. Did your out-of-the-money buys actually pay off? Most people are surprised by the answer, and it's the fastest way to stop repeating the same mistake.

Mistakes I see all the time

  • Buying far out of the money because it's cheap. A low price isn't the same as good value. Low delta usually means low odds.
  • Not checking break-even before buying. It takes five seconds: strike plus premium. If that number looks unrealistic for the time you have, pick a different strike.
  • Forgetting about time decay. An out-of-the-money option loses value every day the stock sits still, even if it never moves against you.
  • Picking strikes differently every trade. If you never write down why you chose a strike, you can never learn which choices work. A simple journal fixes this.

If you sell options, flip it around

Everything above is from the buyer's side. If you sell options, like covered calls or cash-secured puts, you're on the other side of the same trade, and the logic flips.

Sellers usually pick out-of-the-money strikes on purpose. A lower delta means a better chance the option expires worthless and you keep the whole premium. The catch is that you collect less. Many sellers aim for somewhere around a 0.20 to 0.30 delta as a balance between income and the odds of being assigned. If you run the wheel strategy, you make this exact choice every single week.

Watch the video

Prefer to see it on a real option chain? I walk through this same NVIDIA example, step by step, in this video.

Frequently asked questions

Is it better to buy in-the-money or out-of-the-money options?

Neither is better in every case. In-the-money options cost more but need a smaller move to make money, and they hold up better if the stock stalls. Out-of-the-money options are cheap and can return a bigger percentage, but the stock has to move a lot, and quickly, before they pay off. If you are not sure, slightly in the money is the more forgiving choice.

What delta should I look for when buying a call?

Many traders who buy calls or puts on a strong opinion look for a delta between about 0.60 and 0.80. That puts the strike slightly in the money, so the option moves closely with the stock without costing as much as a deep in-the-money contract. Lower deltas are cheaper but behave more like a lottery ticket.

How do I work out the break-even price of an option?

For a call you buy, break-even at expiration is the strike plus the premium you paid per share. For a put you buy, it is the strike minus the premium. A $105 call bought for $9.85 breaks even at $114.85.

Why are in-the-money options more expensive?

Because part of their price is real value you could capture today. A $105 call on a $111 stock is already $6 in the money, so it costs at least that much plus some time value on top. An out-of-the-money option is made entirely of time value, which is why it is cheaper and why it can fade to zero.

What does "at the money" mean?

An option is at the money when its strike is at, or very close to, the current stock price. These options tend to have a delta near 0.50 and carry the most time value of any strike.

Questions about this, or about options in general? Leave a comment on the video and I'll answer it. Happy investing.

This guide is for education only and isn't financial advice. Options carry real risk, including losing everything you paid for the contract. Prices in this guide are examples to show how the ideas work, not live quotes.

Find the strikes that work for you

OptionsVault keeps every trade, strike and result in one place, so you can see which choices actually made you money. Free to start.